Follow the Dollar: How Library Ebook Pricing Actually Works

One Book, Three Prices

Pick up Kristin Hannah's The Women at your local bookstore. It costs $18.

Buy the Kindle edition. $14.99. You own it forever.

Now check what your library paid for the same book in digital form. $60. And that license expires in 24 months. After two years, the library has to pay again for a file that costs nothing to store, nothing to shelve, and nothing to replace.

That\'s not a typo. That\'s the system working as designed.

Here's what real libraries are actually paying, documented by Timberland Regional Library in Washington State:

Look at that audiobook. $95 for a two-year rental. The consumer buys it once for $20 and keeps it forever.

This isn\'t one library getting a bad deal. According to a 2025 Computers in Libraries study, the average library ebook license costs $54.62 while the average Kindle price is $13.66. That\'s a 4x markup. For the same file.

The Markup

Let\'s be precise about what "4x" means across the Big Five publishers, because they don\'t all extract the same way. They've each designed a slightly different trap.

Source: ReadersFirst Publisher Price Watch, Good e-Reader pricing breakdown.

Notice the variation. Simon & Schuster has historically been the most reasonable, but that was before KKR bought them in October 2023 for $1.62 billion. We'll come back to that.

HarperCollins pioneered the 26-checkout model in 2011. At the time, librarians were furious. Fifteen years later, 26 checkouts looks generous compared to what Hachette and Macmillan are doing with pure time-based expiration. The industry moved the floor, not the ceiling.

If you're presenting to a board: The multiplier table above is the slide. One table. No commentary needed. Let your board ask why a digital file with zero marginal cost charges 4x the consumer price and then disappears.

The Expiration Trap

The markup is only the first extraction. The second is that the license vanishes.

When your library buys a physical book for $18, it sits on the shelf until it falls apart, typically lasting 50+ circulations over years of use (a common industry benchmark, though actual lifespan varies by binding and handling). You own it. You can repair it, donate it, sell it at a book sale, lend it to another library.

When your library "buys" a $60 ebook license, it expires. After 24 months or a set number of checkouts (whichever comes first) the file disappears from your catalog. To offer the same book next year, you pay again. Full price.

Here's the math that should make you angry:

• Ebook license: $60 every 2 years
• 10 years of access: 5 renewals = $300
• Physical paperback: $17, owned permanently, 50+ circulations
• The ebook costs 17.6x the paperback over a decade

For a James Patterson Hachette title at $68.25 per license, four years of access costs $136.50. The hardcover is $28.99 and you own it forever.

But here\'s the statistic that reveals the entire game. OverDrive\'s own data shows that Macmillan titles averaged only 8.5 checkouts during a 2-year license period. The checkout cap was 52. That's a utilization rate of 16%.

And 79% of those licenses expired because of the time limit, not the checkout cap.

Read that again. The publishers designed a system with two triggers (time and usage) knowing that time would be the one that fires. The checkout cap is theater. The clock is the revenue engine.

Source: Jane Friedman, citing OverDrive data on Macmillan lending patterns.

Meanwhile, the option to avoid this trap is disappearing. In 2019, 34% of Big Five library ebooks were available on perpetual access terms (pay once, keep forever, like a physical book). By 2024, that number dropped to 15%. A 56% collapse in five years. Source: Words and Money: State of the Library Ebook Market.

The publishers didn't just raise prices. They eliminated the alternative.

The Price Ratchet

Library ebook prices aren\'t just high. They\'re rising faster than everything around them.

• Consumer Kindle ebook prices: relatively flat (based on informal price tracking, 2019–2024; no comprehensive public dataset exists)
• Library ebook prices: +1.9% per year (per Coffman 2025)
• Library ebook prices are rising 6x faster than consumer prices

But that's the average. Individual publishers are far more aggressive. ReadersFirst documented the 2024 increases:

• HarperCollins: +17.8% on ebooks, +17.5% on audiobooks. Annualized rate: 12.9% per year. At that rate, library prices double every 5.6 years.
• Macmillan: +20% on ebooks in a single year.
• Hachette: +4% on ebooks, +20% on audiobooks.

Here\'s the tell that proves this is a policy choice, not a cost-driven outcome: consumer audiobook prices are falling. Audible consumer prices have generally trended downward based on informal tracking, though no comprehensive public dataset exists for comparison. Library audiobook prices rose 3.6% per year per ReadersFirst data. Publishers cut consumer prices to compete for subscribers while raising library prices because libraries can\'t walk away. That\'s not a market. That\'s a shakedown.

The aggregate five-year trend: average library ebook cost rose from $35.54 (2019) to $47.69 (2024). A 34% increase in five years. Source: Coffman, Computers in Libraries, May 2025.

If you're in acquisitions: Pull your own OverDrive invoices from 2019 and 2024. Calculate your per-title cost increase. I promise it\'s worse than the average, because the average includes backlist titles that barely moved. Your frontlist (the books patrons actually want) increased faster.

Where Every Dollar Goes

This is the part nobody talks about. When your library pays $55 for an ebook license, where does the money actually go?

The exact splits between OverDrive and the Big Five publishers are not publicly disclosed. OverDrive is a private company owned by KKR and publishes no financial reports. That alone should concern you: a monopoly platform controlling public library infrastructure with zero public financial transparency.

But we can reconstruct the math from what is documented. OverDrive\'s indie publisher distribution terms show a roughly 50/50 revenue split. Big Five deals are separately negotiated and likely more favorable to the publishers, but the indie terms reveal OverDrive\'s baseline appetite.

Using published contract standards and a $55 library ebook:

Source: Revenue split reconstructed from Jane Friedman's author earnings analysis and typical Big Five contract terms (authors generally receive 25% of publisher net on ebook sales, per industry reporting).

Let that settle. Your library pays $55 for a file that expires in two years. The author (the person who actually wrote the book) receives somewhere between $6.87 and $9.62. The distribution platform that hosts the file takes as much as or more than the company that edited, designed, and marketed it.

I\'ve worked in the vendor side of this industry. I\'ve seen how these distribution economics get structured. The platform fee is where the extraction lives. OverDrive doesn\'t write books. It doesn\'t edit them. It doesn't market them. It hosts a file and manages DRM. For that, it takes 30–50% of every transaction flowing through the public library system.

And on top of the per-title revenue split, libraries pay OverDrive approximately $6,000 per year as a flat platform access fee. Source: WVUA23 local reporting on library digital costs.

You pay to access the store. Then you pay the store's markup. Then the product you bought disappears.

The KKR Problem

In June 2020, KKR acquired OverDrive for approximately $775 million. OverDrive controls roughly 90% of the US public library digital lending market through the Libby app.

In October 2023, KKR acquired Simon & Schuster for $1.62 billion. Simon & Schuster publishes roughly 12% of US trade books (per market share estimates from industry analysts).

One company now owns:

• The platform that distributes 90% of library ebooks
• A publisher that produces 12% of the books on that platform

There is no documented regulatory firewall between these two businesses. No public financial disclosure. When Library Journal raised the obvious conflict-of-interest question, OverDrive CEO Steve Potash responded with "business as usual."

Neither the DOJ nor the FTC challenged the Simon & Schuster acquisition on library pricing grounds. The antitrust concern that was raised (and rejected) was about retail publisher consolidation. Nobody in the regulatory process asked what happens when the same private equity firm controls both the pipe and the product flowing through it.

Here's what happens: KKR can influence pricing on both sides of the transaction. As the platform owner, it sets the distribution terms. As the publisher owner, it sets the license price. The library sits at the end of this chain with no leverage and no alternative.

And there\'s a clock ticking. KKR acquired OverDrive in June 2020. The typical private equity hold period is 5–7 years (a well-documented industry norm). We\'re now at year 5.5. Every decision OverDrive makes (every price increase, every contract term, every piece of testimony against library-friendly legislation) should be evaluated through this lens: does it increase the company's valuation for a potential exit? Price increases do. Margin expansion does. Market consolidation does.

For a deeper look at the PE playbook in action, see From Gutenberg to Gouging and the Potash testimony analysis.

Other Countries Don't Do This

The US model is not inevitable. Other countries handle library ebook lending without the extraction.

Denmark launched a model where new titles are available via publisher licenses, but titles six months or older shift to a per-loan fee of approximately 15-18 Danish kroner (roughly $2-3 USD). Libraries pay for what patrons actually use, with no time-based expiration, no bulk license purchases that sit unused. Denmark established Public Lending Rights in 1946; the digital extension preserves the per-use logic. Source: International Publishers Association.

Sweden uses a similar per-use model for backlist titles at roughly $1.20 per loan. Source: Tandfonline, "Perceptions of e-lending in Scandinavian libraries," 2024.

Australia's library ebook supplier Wheelers Books has documented library ebook pricing trending toward retail parity, the opposite trajectory from the US.

The structural difference: in Scandinavia, e-lending negotiations involve cultural policy actors (national libraries, municipal bodies) as counterparties, not individual libraries negotiating alone against multinational publishers. The asymmetry that enables US extraction doesn't exist because the other side of the table has actual power.

Rebecca Giblin\'s e-Lending Project at the University of Melbourne analyzed nearly 100,000 ebooks across the US, Canada, UK, Australia, and New Zealand. It\'s the most comprehensive cross-national study available. If you want to understand what "normal" looks like outside the US ebook pricing bubble, start there.

What You Can Do About It

Understanding the extraction is step one. Here's how to fight it.

Pull your own numbers

Request your library\'s OverDrive invoices for 2019 and 2024. Calculate your actual cost-per-checkout and compare it to physical circulation cost. For most libraries, ebook cost-per-circ is 2–4x physical (per the Coffman study). That\'s the number your board needs to see.

Format it simply: "We paid $X for digital lending that served Y checkouts. The same money in physical books would have served Z checkouts." Don't editorialize. The math does the work.

Demand price transparency

Ask OverDrive what percentage of your title purchases they retain as platform fee. They almost certainly won't answer. Document the refusal. A monopoly platform controlling public library infrastructure that refuses to disclose its take rate is a fact worth putting in front of your board, your city council, and your state library association.

Join or form a consortium

The Coffman study documented Port Townsend Library's consortium model: annual consortium fee of $9,131 gives access to 144,000+ titles at $0.54 per circulation. The median individual library cost: $0.93 per circulation. Consortium pricing cuts your per-circ cost by 42%.

If your state doesn't have a digital lending consortium, talk to your state library association about starting one. Collective bargaining is the single most effective tool against monopoly pricing. For negotiation tactics, see Consortium Power Plays.

Negotiate license terms

Push for perpetual access on backlist titles. Use the Macmillan 8.5-checkout statistic as your evidence: "Our data shows licenses expire from time limits, not usage. We're paying for 52 checkouts and getting 8. We want terms that reflect actual use."

For red flags to watch for in vendor contracts, use the Contract Audit Checklist. For the specific contract language that enables pricing exploitation, see The Contract Traps.

Support legislation

DC's B26-0490, the Library E-book Pricing Fairness Amendment Act, is the most significant active legislative effort to address library ebook pricing. Multiple states are exploring similar measures. Track them at the State Library Legislation Tracker.

If you're in a state without active legislation, talk to your state library association about model legislation. The DC bill\'s framework (requiring reasonable pricing terms for library ebook licenses) is replicable.

Explore alternatives

OverDrive isn't the only option anymore. Palace Project (operated by Lyrasis) is an open-source, library-governed alternative. cloudLibrary (bibliotheca) serves small and mid-size libraries. The CDL model has legal limitations after the Hachette ruling, but the principle of library-controlled digital lending is worth understanding.

Publish your data

Make your OverDrive invoices public. The pricing asymmetry survives because it\'s invisible. Most patrons have no idea their library pays $60 for a file they\'d buy for $14.99. Most board members have no idea digital lending can consume 30% or more of the collections budget. Most legislators have no idea the same private equity firm owns both the platform and the publisher.

Sunlight is the cheapest disinfectant. One library publishing its OverDrive invoices is a data point. Twenty libraries publishing is a pattern. A hundred is a movement.

The Bottom Line

A consumer pays $14.99 for an ebook and owns it forever. Your library pays $55 for the same file and it disappears in two years. Of that $55, the author gets less than $10. The platform that hosts the file takes up to half. The prices are rising 6x faster than consumer prices. The option to buy permanently is vanishing. And the company that controls 90% of the distribution infrastructure also owns one of the publishers.

This is not a market failure. Markets require competition, transparency, and the ability to walk away. Library ebook pricing has none of those. This is extraction: systematic, documented, and accelerating.

The question for your library isn\'t whether you can afford ebooks. It\'s whether you can afford to keep paying without understanding where the money goes. Now you understand. What you do with that knowledge is up to you.